Your Avatar Alternative

I finally saw District 9 over the weekend.  I enjoyed it immensely and I think I was well timed in seeing it right after Avatar.  After all, they both cover similar themes (humans disregard for “others”, corporate greed, and the inherent corruption of a private military) but they couldn’t be more different in their approaches.  In the end, I think District 9 is the movie I’ll be watching more in the future.  There are a few reasons for it:

1.  The Prawns are more interesting than the Navi.  Now, granted, they’re physically repulsive but that’s the point.  By not being idealized beings, you share some of the feelings of the humans in the movie.  While the Navi are pure and right in everything they do, the Prawns are more believable as a race.

2.  Let’s hear it for a non-clichéd, interesting main character.  Wikus is a half wit “yes man” who doesn’t think much beyond what he’s told to do until he’s contaminated.  In the last act of the film, he finds his backbone and humanity in a realistic, unforced way.  His “going native” is unwanted and creates tension in the story, as opposed to becoming a perfect blue warrior.

3.  The politics feel more genuine.  District 9 is set in South Africa and deals with the very issues that inform life there.  It’s ideas are natural outgrowths of real situations.  Avatar has an environmentalist/pacifist political bent which gets thrown aside the second it’s time to go to war.  I don’t know that either film presents a deep exploration of the origins of corporate greed, but District 9 personalizes the message better through Wikus’ own father in law being the face of it. 

I’m a fan of both large, well done blockbusters and “little films that could.”  Both films are masterfully told, as I mentioned about Avatar in my last post.  Both directors know how to weave tense sequences that manage to surprise you.  But only one of the films has a script with originality and a strong sense of character.  That’s why I think District 9 will probably be the better regarded film twenty years from now.


3 thoughts on “Your Avatar Alternative

  1. I have to agree with about District 9. I wanted to see how the real story played out in South Africa. I enjoyed the fact that the main character’s transition also included a better understanding of the language used by the Prawns. What did drive me crazy was his unwillingness to help until it was absolutely pulling at his morals. But I believe that to be part of the movie that made it better also. It helped to pull me into the story.

    As far as Avatar is concerned, I have not seen it. So that being said, I am glad you enjoyed it.

  2. I have yet to see Avatar but I had to comment on your post concerning ‘District 9’. I found it to be one of those movies that reminds me of some of the most interesting Sci-Fi books I ever read. It wasn’t a rollicking thrill ride but it kept me interested through to the end because of its serious treatment of the subject matter.

    Avatar look amazing but everything I’ve heard so far has been that its beautiful yet formulaic. Like its a new of way of seeing something you’ve seen over and over. Still want to see it, but I’m only partially excited about the story.

    We’ll see.

  3. I have to agree with your assessment. One thing I will add……….Avatar was just something for James Cameron to pad his ego with. Story was below average, but the effects were great. I forgive him for this since he made one of the greatest films of all time…………….T2.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s